The Black Tie Guide
Part One: The Rules, the Cloth and the Facings

A Point of View, Not a Uniform
Before I get ahead of my skis, a word about the limitations of writing a guide to black tie. I’ve been writing about fine menswear since 2009, and I think I have a reasonable grasp of the subject. But I’m no Alan Flusser or Bernhard Roetzel, and I’d encourage you to read widely. Flusser’s Dressing the Man and Roetzel’s Gentleman: A Timeless Guide to Fashion are good places to start. I’d also recommend Hugo Jacomet, one of the great menswear voices of today, and his writing at Parisian Gentleman. This is one person’s opinion in a sea of opinions, and black tie has never stood as still as its rules might suggest.
There’s also the small matter that we make things we’d quite like you to buy. That inevitably informs what I notice. I spend a great deal of time thinking about how a silk catches the light and how a bow sits against a lapel. That is the point of view I can offer you.
Black tie becomes interesting when you stop thinking of it as a list of objects to purchase and assemble. The ingredients are familiar enough: dinner jacket and trousers, white evening shirt, black bow tie and black shoes. Then come the choices: waistcoat or cummerbund; studs or a concealed placket; a textured Marcella bib or a softly pleated front; patent leather or a pair of beautifully polished Oxfords. And, though the old guard might disagree, I don’t object to a discreet dress watch.
All of that is before you’ve chosen the cut of your dinner suit. I’d encourage you to be playful and curious, but to stay within the framework.
Black tie is like a game of football. You have the field, the ball, the players and the rules. What happens after that is the bit you remember.
Two Princes, Two Chapters of Black Tie
The first Prince of Wales in this story became Edward VII. According to Henry Poole & Co., in 1865 he asked the house for a short evening coat to wear to informal dinners at Sandringham. Poole made it in celestial blue. The familiar American story comes later: in 1886, James Brown Potter is said to have encountered the prince and taken the idea of the short evening coat back to Tuxedo Park, New York. Poole cannot verify Potter’s order in its surviving ledgers, so I’d keep the story as a good piece of dinner-table folklore rather than a firm account of how the tuxedo crossed the Atlantic.
The second Prince of Wales was the future Edward VIII, better known to menswear enthusiasts as the Duke of Windsor after his abdication. The Metropolitan Museum of Art credits him with introducing midnight blue as an alternative to black evening wear in the 1920s. He’s a useful figure to look at from that interwar period, when black tie gained ground and dinner clothes offered more room for individuality: double-breasted jackets, softer shirt fronts, turn-down collars and, in warmer climates, the white dinner jacket.
If you want to see why I return to that period, pull up a few old Esquire illustrations. Look at the rise of the trousers, the sweep of the lapels and the amount of shirt showing above the waist. Those proportions have more to teach you than a list of rules.
Read the Cloth, Not the Label
Debrett’s is as good a place as any to start. Its black-tie guidance names black wool barathea or ultrafine herringbone for the dinner jacket. The other two cloths below are my additions, not recommendations I’d put in Debrett’s mouth.
- Barathea. My starting point for a classic black dinner jacket. The surface has a fine, pebbled texture and usually reads quite matt, which is lovely against satin. Barathea can be woven in silk too; the word describes the cloth’s construction, not the fibre.
- Fine worsted twill. Look closely and you’ll see a subtle diagonal. A fine, sober version can give a dinner suit a clean line. I’d judge it by the way it hangs and how much it shines, rather than by the name on the bunch.
- Fine herringbone. A twill whose diagonal reverses, creating a little zigzag. For evening wear, I like it fine enough that it reads as black across the room and reveals itself only up close.
- Plain weave. An over-one, under-one weave. It can make a crisp, light-feeling dinner cloth. A wool–mohair blend is one option here; the blend tells you what the yarns are made of, not how they are woven.
I’ve had good experiences with cloths from Holland & Sherry, Dormeuil, Loro Piana, Zegna, Scabal and Vitale Barberis Canonico. But I wouldn’t shop by the selvedge alone. Put the cloth beside your chosen facing and look at the two together under warm light. Then take a few steps back. That’s a better test than holding a swatch an inch from your nose.


The Facings: Where the Silk Comes In
The facings are the material you see on the lapels. If you’re having a jacket made bespoke, you can usually discuss precisely what goes there; with made-to-measure, the options depend on what the maker offers. Ask what the cloth is made of. “Satin” describes the weave, not a guarantee of silk. A facing can be made from silk or another fibre, such as cupro or polyester.
- Silk satin: the glamour cloth. My first choice. The weave lets yarns float over several others before interlacing, which gives the surface its smoothness and lustre. Against a black wool barathea it catches the light in a way I’ve never tired of.
- Silk grosgrain or faille: the quieter choice. Both have crosswise ribs, though the names aren’t interchangeable. A fine ribbed facing gives you texture without the broad reflection of satin. If a tailor calls it grosgrain, ask to see the actual swatch. What matters is the scale of the rib and what it does next to the wool.
- Silk barathea: the discreet choice. The fine grain is appealing in its own right. On a wool barathea jacket, though, I often find there isn’t enough contrast. I’d sooner consider it against a smoother wool, where the silk has room to show itself.
I’d bring the bow tie to the fitting if you have one in mind. You don’t have to match the facing thread for thread. It’s enough that the textures sit well together and one doesn’t make the other look dull by accident.

Next Stop: The Cut of Your Suit
In Part Two, we’ll get to the decisions that shape the whole silhouette: the jacket and trousers, the shirt, and whether a waistcoat or cummerbund makes more sense for the suit you want to wear.
For the curious
- Alan Flusser, Dressing the Man
- Bernhard Roetzel, Gentleman: A Timeless Guide to Fashion
- Hugo Jacomet, Parisian Gentleman
- Debrett’s black-tie dress code
- Henry Poole & Co. on the dinner jacket
- The Metropolitan Museum of Art’s Duke of Windsor evening suit
Black Tie in Practice





